Benitos Pizzeria & Cafe is a pizza restaurant in Warwick, NY. Open: Mon–Thu 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM; Fri–Sat 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM; Sun 12:00 – 9:00 PM. Phone: (845) 986-6033. Average rating is 4.6 stars from 245 reviews. Website: http://www.benitoswarwickny.com/.
Benitos Pizzeria & Cafe
Call Now Directions
Review
Exterior view of Benito's Pizza with outdoor seating. — Benitos Pizzeria & Cafe
4.6 245 reviews Today 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Real Italian Recipes, Warwick's Favorite Pizza Since 1987

Family recipes from Silvio and Benito, made with the finest ingredients for dine-in, takeout, and catering.

About Us

A freshly baked pizza on a serving tray in a cozy restaurant. — Benitos Pizzeria & Cafe
A freshly baked pizza on a serving tray in a cozy restaurant.

Silvio and his son Benito opened their doors on Ronald Reagan Blvd in 1987 with a straightforward mission: cook the food they grew up eating, using the recipes that had been passed down through the family. Nearly four decades later, that mission hasn't changed. The menu still runs on those same handwritten techniques, and the dining room still feels like you walked into someone's home rather than a restaurant.

The kitchen turns out New York-style pizza with a crust that has the right pull and char, but the cafe side of the menu is just as serious. Guests come back specifically for the gnocchi primavera, the salmon puttanesca, and the Fireman's Soup, a bowl that regulars describe as impossible to put into words. The buffalo chicken pizza has its own loyal following too.

With a 4.6-star rating built on 245 reviews, Benito's has earned the trust of the Warwick Valley community and visitors alike. Out-of-towners from as far as Michigan have sat down, eaten, and said they felt like family. That's not an accident. It's what happens when a family runs a restaurant the same honest way for 37 years.

What We Offer

Benito's serves the Warwick Valley three ways: sit down and stay a while, grab it to go, or let them handle your next event.

Dine-in is the full experience, friendly staff, a warm room, and a menu that rewards exploration beyond the pizza. Take-out is available for every item on the menu, ready for pickup when you are. And the catering program covers both on-premises and off-premises events, so whether you're planning a rehearsal dinner, a corporate lunch, or a neighborhood party, the same family recipes that have been feeding Warwick since 1987 can anchor your table.

The kitchen is open seven days a week, Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and Friday and Saturday until 10:00 PM. Sunday hours begin at noon.

Gallery

Take a look at our space and what we have to offer

“Best pizza ever, great friendly ambience, excellent waitstaff. And the Fireman's Soup is delicious beyond description!”

— Patricia Daly

What Our Customers Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers

Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
a year ago
"Best pizza ever, great friendly ambience, excellent waitstaff. And the Fireman's Soup is delicious beyond description!"
— Patricia Daly
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
3 years ago
"I got the Strawberry salad from here today. It was really good. The staff was really friendly. They treat you like family. I from out of town (Michigan) and felt cozy and comfortable eating there. I hope to go back tomorrow and try the pizza."
— Chris Nagy
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
a year ago
"Very tasty pizza! Always a friendly welcome too! Try the buffalo chicken pizza- you won’t be disappointed!"
— Rob Quicke
7 months ago
"YOU WILL GET SICK this was the worst experience I’ve had in orange county NY. From RAW food to hairs, multiple hairs in my pasta dish, dirty lettuce in my grandma’s salad, flies flying around your plate the server was very nice and was great at her job but the food at this place is a health hazard the health department should shut this place down.RAW FOOD!! Dirt and filth ABSOLUTELY UNACCEPTABLE"
— Karbon Garson
⭐⭐⭐
3 months ago
"pizza is pretty good but the place has weird energy and ambiance. cash and check only. weird. its 2026."
— Sandy W

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Benito's Pizzeria and Cafe located?

Benito's is at 32 Ronald Reagan Blvd in Warwick, NY 10990, serving the Warwick Valley and surrounding communities.

What are your hours?

Monday through Thursday and Sunday, the kitchen is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM (Sunday opens at noon). Friday and Saturday hours extend to 10:00 PM. Benito's is open all seven days.

Do you offer takeout?

Yes. Every item on the menu is available for takeout. Just call ahead or stop by and the team will have your order ready.

Does Benito's do catering?

Absolutely. Benito's offers catering both on and off premises. Whether you need food delivered to your venue or want to host your event at the restaurant, reach out to discuss your needs.

What dishes are most popular besides pizza?

Reviewers frequently highlight the Fireman's Soup, the gnocchi primavera, the salmon puttanesca, and the buffalo chicken pizza as must-try items.

How long has Benito's been open?

Benito's has been serving authentic Italian food in Warwick since 1987, founded by Silvio and his son Benito using their family's own recipes.

Is Benito's good for first-time visitors or out-of-towners?

Many reviewers note that first visits feel immediately comfortable. The staff is known for treating guests warmly, and the menu offers enough variety that there's something for everyone, from classic New York-style slices to homemade Italian entrees.

Hours of Operation

Open Now · Closes at 9:00 PM
Monday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday Today 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Sunday 12:00 – 9:00 PM
79° Clear Warwick
Wed 90° 72°
Thu 88° 67°
Fri 84° 63°
Sat 70° 66°
Sun 77° 58°
Mon 80° 53°
Tue 81° 62°

Get In Touch

Ready to get started? Contact us today!

Save to Contacts

More places nearby

Other spots near here, whatever their type. Tap one to open its page.

Italian Restaurant ★ 4.4 (369)
Bella Luna Restaurant & Pizzeria
12 mi2877 NY-94, Blooming Grove, NY 10914
$$
Chinese Restaurant ★ 4.0 (42)
Warwick Kitchen
steps away30 Ronald Reagan Blvd, Warwick

Contact Benitos Pizzeria & Cafe

Send a note and Benitos Pizzeria & Cafe will get back to you. No account needed.

Add an email or a phone so they can reply.

Best time to reach you

Report an issue

See something off? Tell us. We’ll fix it and improve the listing for everyone. No account required.